NZ forum
the worlds most secret club

From the beginning, we knew we would be among the new generation of “older” parents. Terri and I met in Nepal, where I was the Director of an aid agency and she was doing volunteer work with the Mother Theresa Hospice. After a long-distance romance, I moved to New Zealand to be with her. From the time we started to share our hopes and dreams, we found ourselves in complete agreement on the question of children. We both wanted two girls two years apart. Following our marriage in 1984, we lived five years as a childless couple with all the freedom that allowed. In August of 1988, we felt we had indulged ourselves enough, and decided it was time to start our family. Of course, we expected an immediate pregnancy followed by a problem-free birth.

After a year of trying, with Terri still not pregnant, we visited fertility specialist Richard Fisher. But shortly after hearing our IVF options, I awoke one day to find a card on the table for me – a Father’s Day Card! Terri was pregnant – without any intervention by the good Doctor Fisher.

We immediately began the preparing for our impending family – arranging the baby’s room: clothes, toys, change table, bassinet, carry basket, and then thinking further: pre-school, school, university! We were becoming a family – with a family future ahead of us. Life was perfect! The following weeks were exciting - planning and buying for the baby.

And then, one day, I came home to find Terri distraught and in tears. She told me she had miscarried.

The perfect life was all over – all in a flash.

This was so unexpected – and so unusual. After all, a miscarriage was a rare occurrence, wasn’t it? Why had it happened to us? How could we be so unlucky? What did we do wrong?

Naturally, Terri was devastated. I was upset and saddened, and confused over this tragedy. What could I do? What was the role of the father-to-be (or not-to-be in this case)? I could offer comfort to Terri in my own feeble way, but I think she was the stronger of us.

But I was still baffled over why this exceptional tragedy could happen to us. Who could I talk to who would understand? Our families all knew about the pregnancy, so obviously they had to be told what had happened. And that is where I became enlightened. In talking with my mother, she informed me “of course you know I lost a baby between your brother and sister.” And then, “Maybe you didn’t know that your sister lost her first pregnancy.” As we informed family, we learned of more miscarriages; it seemed that nearly every mother had experienced at least one loss among their successful deliveries.

What was this, a conspiracy? I became aware that we were now members of one of the biggest secret clubs in the world – parents who experience miscarriages. I realised there is nothing bizarre or unusual about miscarriages at all. In fact, they occur far more frequently than anyone lets on. But why was this such a secret? They are a natural and surprisingly frequent part of the human species’ reproductive process. And there was nothing to be ashamed of or hide from.

Why are hopeful parents not aware of the frequency of miscarriages? Why are they such a secret? There is nothing at all “wrong” with the parents. It is, in fact, a perfectly natural, though tragic, event. While there is no cause to celebrate the occasion, it shouldn’t be hidden from the world either. The more open this ‘secret club’ becomes, the less traumatic will be the impact on the many, many parents-to-be who are yet to inevitably experience it. The work of Miscarriage Support in educating people to the reality of life is invaluable.

Oh, and in the end… we now have two lovely girls – two years apart!

David